Giovanni no Shima – movie review

posted in: Anime Review | 6

Giovanni no Shima head2

I recently watched Giovanni no Shima (Giovanni’s Island) without knowing what I would get to see.

Giovanni no Shima is a Movie that aired in February 2014 and was produced by Production I.G. and Warner Brothers, directed by Nishikubo, Mizuho. It’s partially based on real historic events, for further interest please follow this link

Giovanni no Shima  (13)

“When people die, they rise up into heaven and become stars in the night sky.
Those countless stars fill the sky, shining brightly and eternally, and we live our lives down here, basking in their light…”

Giovanni no Shima  (2)

The movie starts on the sparkling ocean with two old people reminiscing about their past onboard of a ship heading to the Island Shikotan, their direction is a class reunion from their elementary school. After the intro scene the Movie switches to the old man’s childhood on Shikotan during the last days of the second world war.

Giovanni no Shima  (1)

I don’t how it was for you, but in my history books from school, we didn’t pay much attention to the pacific war or Japans role in the WWII at all, So I knew nothing about the Soviet involvement in the pacific campaign, aside from a short sidenote.

Giovanni no Shima  (6)

The story centers on a small island, as Japan officialy surrendered, in these last days the russians still wanted to gain something and invaded some islands that actually belonged to Japan. On the island are mainly fisherman and a small community of civillians.

Giovanni no Shima  (5)

That gunshot was so loud, that my head was ringing *kabooom*

The russians are actually not such mean invaders as one would ecpect, I felt a bit uneasy in the first scene as they stormed the school with the young female teacher and the kids inside Well, the remaining Japanese soldiers were transported to labour camps in another country.

Giovanni no Shima  (7)

The island itself didn’t offer much to exploit for the soviets except a beautiful scenerery.

We experience the story from the perspective of two brothers Junpei and Kanta.

Giovanni no Shima  (9)

As first impression it was a bit weird that the civillians have to divide their homes for incoming russian families that take one half. Also the little school is divided in two parts for russian and japenese kids. They are forced to coexist, at first thats leads to some quarrels. For example each class tried to overpower the other class with singing their morning anthem.

Giovanni no Shima  (10)

Giovanni no Shima  (12)

After a while things turn out more positive, through the thin wooden classroom walls both classes join voices and sing the katyusha song and the japenese one afterwards. The kids also start playing together peacefully and learn a bit of the other nations language. A peaceful coexistence appears possible during the time of these events.

Giovanni no Shima  (16)
The boys are playing with their battery powered railway.

Giovanni no Shima  (14)
The two brothers Junpei and Kanta even befriend with the commanders daughter Tanja, they name themself Giovanni and Campanella because they assume that she can’t pronounce their real names. They eat together with the russian family, who treat the two boys very sincere.

Giovanni no Shima  (17)

This nice utopia still is twisted, the food supply is very limited for the invaded villagers, only the russian army families have some luxury. The japenese citizens are deliberately driven in a corner and forced to smuggle, when the food smuggling is discovered all citizens are forced to leave the Island without exception, it appears really unfair, but after you loose a war you’ve started it’s victor’s justice, a  prominent topic in this movie.

Giovanni no Shima  (20)

The first half was rather friendly, even shortly after the invasion, the things we see through the perspektive Junpei and Kanta are vivid and appear like a relatively normal childhood.

From then on the after war drama unfolds it’s really depressing clockwork. The villagers are put on a huge transport ship, actually expecting to be shipped to the japanese homeland, but the people are thrown into labour camps in another country. It’s cold and people get sick.

Giovanni no Shima  (21)

Junpei and Kanta get seperated from their father. When the two brothers find themselves in difficult situations they remember the story of a book their father once told them, The night on the Galactic Railroad’ (The popular novel) is their way to escape the often harsh post war world, but no magic is involved.

Giovanni no Shima  (23)

At the end the story switches back to the present to the class reunion celebration of both the russians and former japanese villagers. The old Japanese people who were allowed to visit the island, to receive their graduation papers.

Giovanni no Shima  (22)

The Movie actually doesn’t judge from a nationalistic perspective, it doesn’t blame the russians diretly for their actions nevertheless from todays view on things, it is just wrong to punish innocent civillians for a war which was started by the countries leaders in the first place. Banishment and compulsory labor this all makes me sick, generally speaking.

Maybe this is a weak point of the movie, not to blame the “invaders” a single time. I think they were directly to blame for the unnecessary suffering of these people.
Sure Japan also commited crimes back then, maybe even worse, but not these civillians!

It’s also true that you won’t create a peaceful relationship with ofsetting each sides guilt, the message of the movie is forgiving and accepting your losses to reach a peaceful relationship.
The Movie tells us about tragedies in life, that you have to accept to be able to go on.

Giovanni no Shima  (24)

The animation style is kept simple, but the characters are still drawn distinctive and appealing. Also the backgrounds look quite pretty with the beautiful island. The voice acting also deserves to be mentioned, the talented actors show us the beauty of the russian language.

Giovanni no Shima leaves the audience with an conciliatory end, but in a also sad silence. I felt really agiated and touched. I intentionally never watched Grave of Fireflies, because it’s sad on a rather disturbing level, but I think Giovanni no Shima is on a similar level with a more positive message, still these kind of movies are hard to digest after everything said and done.

If you are a fan of anime movies in general or like to see some ambitious post war drama, I would recommend Giovanni no Shima, it’s not all sad and partially shows humor.

6 Responses

  1. Hoshiko

    This is one anime movie I’d like to watch. It looks like something light but thoughtful. Plus, I kinda like the artwork. I actually never heard of Giovanni no Shima before so thanks for the post! And my history sucks. We studied about World War II but I forgot everything and often had the events mixed up with World War I. Not the brightest person here, lol.

    • wieselhead

      Yes, it’s quite thoughtful when you engage in the movie.
      I like anime movies in general and Giovanni no Shima was just randomly chosen.
      lol, oh don’t say that, I’m also not strong in every subject ;D

  2. Aya

    Very surprising Production I.G. made this O_O; they usually made something more brutal with a lot of violence,death and blood XD (something that I really like lol) , haven’t watch this but glad it’s not sad like `Grave of the Fireflies`

  3. VIncent

    WoW nice!! For some reason, it remind me of that Studio Ghibli film call Grave of the Fireflies, totally love the way how you laid out the progression of the story. Now you just made me interest in this film that I’m unaware of until now. I especially like the anime when it is relate to World War 1 OR 2 history settings. Got to watch it! Thanks for the blog update^^

    • wieselhead

      At first I thought it was something from Ghiblir.
      Grave of the Fireflies, I never watched that, I guess I can’t digest that sadness ;D
      Ah thats good, it’s a bit difficult to recommend something rather sad.
      I see, but there is not much fighting, if at all but they captured this decade very well in this setting.
      No problem I was already writing on it before the “crybaby” post ahaha.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *